Arbitration and expert evidence
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.22235/rd.v0i13.1215Keywords:
arbitration, expert liability, confidentiality.Abstract
Expert evidence is a controversial question in arbitration, where discussions on how expert evidence should be regulated to achieve that arbitrators receive expert opinions as independent as possible is the usual practice. But it is being forgotten that, strictly speaking, the parties are the ones that designate their own experts and also the ones that could lose the most if the Arbitral Tribunal rejects an expert's arguments due to his or her lack of impartiality. For that reason, this article analyses the grounds why expert evidence is mistrusted, the solutions continuously offered to this respect and their efficiency. In conclusion, it is stated that the most relevant solution to give validity to expert evidence is the existence of mechanisms that enable both the parties and the Arbitral Tribunal to call into question the experts' opinions.
On the other hand, the interest aroused by what has been mentioned above involves that other relevant topics receive less attention. Therefore, this article also studies questions related to expert evidence such as confidentiality, the assessment of evidence and the experts' liability, among others.Downloads
References
ALBALADEJO, Manuel y DÍAZ ALABART, Silvia (Directores), "Comentarios al Código Civil y Compilaciones Forales”, Ed. Revista de Derecho Privado, Madrid, 1991, pág. 49.
CHARTERED INSTITUTE OF ARBITRATORS: “Protocol for the Use of Party-Appointed Expert Witnesses in International Arbitration”, 2007.
CREMADES, B: Centro de Arbitraje de la Industria. Peritaje en el Arbitraje Internacional.Conferencia impartida por el Dr. Bernardo Cremades Sanz-Pastor en la tercera Conferencia Magistral José Luis Siqueiros en México, Distrito Federal, el 16 de enero de 2014.
DE BERTI, G.: Experts and expert witnesses in International Arbitration: Adviser, Advocate or Adjudicator? ARBITRATION YEARBOOK 2011, 53 (Klausegger, Klein, Kremslehner, Petsche, Pitkowitz, Power, Welser & Zeiler eds., 2011)
DE BY, ROBERT A.: ICDR/CIArb/LACBA Conference - International Arbitration in the Pacifi c Rim: Th e Use of Reliance Documents & Expert Witnesses – Effi ciency & Fairness. “A New Focus For Th e Expert Witness Debate In International Arbitrations”. 2014.
DYER, R.: “Th e role of the expert in Arbitration”. Th e Chartered Institute of Arbitration. 2002.
DOWNES AM, Hon. Justice Garry: “Th e use of expert witnesses in Court and International Arbitration Processes”. Sidney 2006.
EL KOSHERI A. S.: “Th e Diff erent Types of Experts with Special Emphasis on LegalExperts (Jura Novit Curia)”. OGEL 3 (2007).
HUNTER, J. Martin: “Experts” in international arbitration”. Kluwer arbitration blog. 7 febrero 2011
HUNTER, J. Martin: “Expert Conferencing and New Methods”. TDM 3 (2007).
IBA: “IBA Rules on the Taking of Evidence in Interational Arbitration, 2010.
ICC: “Reglamento de peritaje”, 2012.
NEWMAN, L. W. y SHEPPARD, B.: “Take the Witness: Cross-Examination in International Arbitration”, 2010.
JIMÉNEZ-BLANCO, G.: “El arbitraje en 55 lecciones prácticas”. Editorial Aranzadi, 2016.
JONES D.: “Party Appointed Expert Witnesses in International Arbitration: A Protocol at Last”. Arbitration International. LCIA. 2008.
Revista de Derecho. Segunda época. Año 12. N.º 13 (julio 2016), 33-86 ISSN 1510-3714 - ISSN On line 2393-6193 86
KIM, K.: “Commentary on Using Legal Experts in International Arbitration”. ICCA international arbitration congress; back to basics?. Kluwer Law International, 2007.
RUTTINGER, G. y MEADOWS, J.:”Using experts in arbitration”. Dispute Resolution Journal Vol. 62, n.º 1 (feb-abril 2007).
QUEEN MARY, UNIVERSITY OF LONDON, CENTRE OF COMMERCIAL LAW
STUDIES, SCHOOL OF INTERNATIONAL ARBITRATION AND ICC):
“Colloquium on Expert Witnesses”, 29th Annual Colloquium of Arbitrators, March 31, 2014.
RIX, B. “Colloquium on Expert Witnesses”, 29th Annual Colloquium of Arbitrators, March 31, 2014.
SACHS, K.: “Protocol on Expert Teaming: A New Approach to Expert Evidence”. Kluwer, 2011.
SKADDEN: Hot topic: “Expert Witnesses in arbitration”, 2012.
TAWIL, G.: “Los Sistemas de Valoración de la Prueba y el Arbitraje Internacional”, en: Revista de Arbitragem e Mediação. São Paulo, Ano 3, Vol. 8, jan./mar. 2006, pp. 221-222.
VON WOBESER, CLAUS “Th e Arbitral Tribunal-Appointed Expert”. OGEL 3 (2007).
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
This publication is attached to the Creative Commons policy.
Political: this magazine provides an access open immediate to its content, based on the principle of that offer to the public an access free to them research helps to a higher Exchange global of knowledge.
Edition covered Dec. 218 / 96. Committee on the role. The reproduction total or partial in form identical or modified written to machine, by the system multigraph, mimeograph, printed, photocopy, scanner, media electronic, etc. not authorized by them editors violates rights reserved. Any use must be requested previously. Them opinions poured by the authors in their articles not reflect necessarily the seem of the Faculty of psychology of the University Catholic of the Uruguay.
